The Cyber Security CIA explained via Calvin and Hobbes

Leave it to my son Kody, who is starting his Cyber Security career to come up with this novel way to explain the CIA triad for Cyber Security.

In InfoSec terms, CIA refers to Confidentiality, Integrity, and Availability. To illustrate how these principles work, let’s look at Calvin and Hobbes.

Calvin and Hobbes create a club called the “Super-Secret-No-Icky-Girls-Allowed” club. During their very first treehouse meeting, they draft a document entitled “member list” and write the names “Calvin” and “Hobbes” on the list. This list is the club’s most valuable asset so Calvin and Hobbes need to maintain the CIA of the asset. The confidentiality of the list is critical as the exposure of the secret member list would cause the entire super-secret club to lose its purpose. The integrity of the list is also important to ensure that unauthorized modifications of the list can’t be made. It would be terrible if Susie’s name were to make it on the list of if Calvin’s name were to be removed. Lastly, the availability of the list is important. When the club meets to have their secret meetings, they need the list do roll call and to ensure that those in attendance are listed.

So now that we’ve got the idea, we can explain how CIA works for business assets. The confidentiality of the asset is necessary to ensure that only those with appropriate privileges and appropriate need can see the asset. The integrity of the asset is necessary to ensure that the data has not been changed and, if it has, a log of changes is kept. The availability of the asset is necessary because it is not of any value if no one can interact with it for its intended purpose.

Why Is It?

Why is it that Internet Crime statistics continue to show that for the criminally inclined internet crime is a very viable and fast growing field?

Why is it that millions of dollars are stolen from end users who simply fail to pay attention to the basics of Information Security like strong pass-phrases and “don’t click the link”?

Why is it that in March of 2010 there was a breach of University student’s personally identifiable information (PII) that numbered over 3.3 million identities being stolen?

Why is it that in 2012 there was a breach of over 6 million IDs from the state of South Carolina IT Infrastructure?

Why is it that online banking theft is at an all time high with thefts against mid size business and metropolitan areas taking center stage?

Why is it that even though unheard amounts of information is being stolen daily that non-cyber security professionals are still very vocal in explaining to experts in the field of cyber security why passwords, pass-phrases, encryption and other basic controls don’t work and are too cumbersome?

  •  Yet in most breach cases if basic information security controls and best practices like defense in depth would have been in place and followed the breach would not have occurred

Why is it that the non- Cyber Security professional’s opinions on what Cyber Security controls are important are often given more weight than the Cyber Security professional’s opinions within an organization?

Why is it that Senior IT and Business managers within an organization still won’t listen to the Cyber Security professionals they employ when it comes to building and maintaining an effective security and control infrastructure?

Why is it that Cyber Security professionals still don’t have the voice they need within most corporations (Government, Public and Private) to actually protect the organization’s data?

Why is it that blame for failure to protect corporate data is quick to be placed on the shoulders of Cyber Security professionals who weren’t listened to in the first place?

Why is it that as experts we really do have the knowledge and ability to protect sensitive corporate data but in most organizations we are not given the power to do so?

Why is it that rhetorical questions are not answered?

© Kevin L. McLaughlin – properly cited use is encouraged

The Talent Within

11/8/2012

In his book “Topgrading: How leading companies win by hiring, coaching and keeping the best people” (2005) Dr. Smart talks about how important it is for a company to not only hire A level talent but then keep and retain them through the years.  I have had the good fortune to work for a company that was very good at this and not only did they hire and retain A players they had a very good internal training program to make sure that the A players they hired were trained and taught the new roles they moved into in order to lessen the knowledge gap and learning curve for the new position.  In this environment efficiency, streamlining, being agile, having solid and well followed processes were the norm.  Needless to say this is a good environment for a talented knowledge professional to work and grow in.  The basic idea was to hire and surround yourself with great and talented A performers and then allow them to make decisions and drive systemic change ongoing.   To me this process of hiring smart and talented people and then promoting them as next step openings become available makes a lot of sense.

Unfortunately, throughout my professional travels what I have often observed is that even in companies with great training programs and who espouse the philosophy of growing talent from within there is a strong psychological tendency to seek outside for the next professional with a briefcase (J  that’s an old joke about how your own company or organization never views you as an expert or qualified candidate, even if the rest of the nation views you that way),  and bypass their internal talent pool.

What a lot of the VPs and directors who are hiring do not realize is that if you have an A player on your staff who is one level lower than the position you are filling they will succeed if you put them in the position, even if they have some knowledge gaps, that is pretty much what A players do.     I know, a lot of you who are reading this are scratching your heads and thinking about all the times a resource is promoted beyond their ability and wondering how that fits in.  The answer is simple, they weren’t an A player or they were an A player who, inherited all B and C players and wouldn’t aggressively cull the herd.

Both competent B and lower level C performers, especially ones that are non-performing destroy any possibility of creating a high performing team.  These lower talented professionals don’t create this less than successful environment on purpose, it is just that they really don’t understand the higher level connections and thought process of the A player and they end up being more of a hindrance and distractor to overall success than they are a key component to the accomplishment of overall success.

There is research study after research study that shows if you have 90+% A players in your management ranks you will be extremely successful in your team and corporate endeavors.  That being said I continue to scratch my head when I see organizations with A level talent who are available to move into a next tier open position go out on a public search to fill the position.  A level talent is very hard to find, and to think that you are going to be able to search outside and find it more readily than you can identify and find it in the work force that has been with you for an extended period of time is simply naive.  What typically happens is that an experienced director or VP is brought in from the outside and they end up after a short amount of time showing that they are a B or low level C talent.  Even more mind boggling to me is that none of the people who were responsible for bringing this less than high end performer into the organization want to admit to making a bad hire so they live with the impact an under talented manager brings to their organization.    The outcome of such a decision is that their true A players are driven from the organization and they take their talents to a competitor, where they are typically extremely successful working and managing at a level their previous employer would not promote them into.

Organizations really need to take a good look at their talent retention programs and give them more than just lip service and they also need to come to the realization that all forced ranking systems do is allow for the B and C players  figure out sly ways to sabotage their talent pool of A players.  Like Ken Blanchard says, organizations should help all of their “employees earn a grade of an A”,  in my opinion the Blanchard approach to talent management will more readily allow you to identify and distinguish between the A, B and C players in your talent pool.

© Kevin L. McLaughlin, probably cited re-use is acceptable

In Cyber Crisis

We are a country in crisis in regards to adopting adequate Information Security practices.   I am not an alarmist but when I review the Cyber Security update that my team compiles and sends out a couple of times per week and see multiple breaches in every update and when I see reports like the one conducted by Adam Dodge or the Verizon Report that show steady amounts of information security breaches every year I have come to believe that we are a country in Cyber crisis.

Puzzling to me is that for some reason we, as a society have decided that the safeguarding of personal information should be a soft skill that is done by committee instead of by the certified and trained professionals we hire into Information Security roles.  Interesting enough the members who are sitting on the committees making Information Security and data protection decisions are often times not Information Security professionals.   To use an analogy – it seems that instead of deferring to our qualified “pilots” we are allowing the passengers to fly the airplane without providing them flight instructions first.  If we really want to protect our corporate data then we cannot  keep making Information Security decisions, such as should Personally Identifiable Information (PII) be encrypted, by consensus.  We also need to see the cost benefit with hiring Information Security professionals and then listening to their advice. Due to a large data breach the State of South Carolina recently ended up paying $12 million that could have been put to better use; they could have asked any of us Information Security professionals if the data they lost should have been encrypted at rest and in transit to save $12 million.  Instead (and this is pure conjecture on my part) they probably made the decision not to do so by a consensus of the CIO and other IT professionals, none of whom were trained Information Security professionals.

In my personal life I refrain from telling my accountant how to complete my taxes or from telling my surgeon where and how to make her surgical cuts.  It is time, if we truly want to protect our data or the data we are entrusted to safeguard, for our communities to start adapting the course of action that Information Security Professionals and Information Security Standards advise. If we don’t start allowing our certified and trained professionals to specifically mandate how organizational PII, Intellectual Property, e-PHI, collectively referred to as restricted data, should be protected we will continue to allow this data to be lost or stolen.

While there is no silver bullet that will prevent 100% of this type of data loss most experienced and certified information security professionals know that there are many controls and safeguards we can put in place, if allowed to do so,  that will minimize the loss of restricted data.

Note – my use of the words Information Security is synonymous with Information Assurance.

© Kevin L. McLaughlin, probably cited re-use is acceptable

A Myth of Information Security: All data needs to be protected!

When you think about the total amount of data that goes across an organization on a daily basis protecting all of it becomes a daunting, if not impossible, task. It is hard to wrap one’s mind around how much a gigabyte of data is, let alone trying to conceptually understand what a terabyte of data is! It seems that current regulatory requirements and Information Security professionals are saying that all this data needs to be protected? Not true… that is a myth generated to scare the masses! For most business units and organizations the reality is that only 5-10% of the data that transverses their infrastructure or sits within electronic and physical filing cabinets is sensitive enough to need protection.

How do we differentiate between data that needs to be protected and data that does not need protected? One answer is for us to embrace an enterprise wide data classification scheme that allows the owner of the data to decide which of their data should be treated as:

  • Highly Restricted
  • Sensitive
  • Public

Once data owners classify their data they can then make smart choices about which data to protect very tightly and which data not to protect as well. This also allows the site data owners to save money by purchasing tools or establishing business processes that protect the 5-10% of data that requires extra protection vs. trying to protect 100% of the data flowing through their work areas.

By focusing on the small amount (5-10%) of data that truly needs to be protected we can lessen the complexity and obtrusiveness of data protection and regulatory compliance while reducing the cost of people, time and dollars. This reduced focus and scope is beneficial to the organization’s bottom line.

Yes, there is certain data that we are legally required to protect and secure and doing so can require small sacrifices and inconveniences on our part, similar to having to wear a seat belt when driving a car.  However, if we focus our attention and tightened security on the small percentage of data that needs to be protected we might actually find out that there really is such a thing as a cost effective Information Security program.

© Kevin L. McLaughlin, probably cited re-use is acceptable

Common Sense Requires No Policy

As a Senior Information Security professional I am often asked if we should have a policy that requires our Business Community members to do “X”.  In many of these cases the person is asking for a policy to be written that says things like: Business Community members will adhere to the laws surrounding the safeguarding of regulated data or that Business Community members will not disclose a person’s private medical information to 3rd parties.   Now, when asked a question that consists of what people in common would agree on, such as do I really have to follow the federal and state laws while at work, I have to wonder why we would want to implement a policy to tell people to follow their common sense.  Really, shouldn’t a person’s common sense kick in and make them very aware that they are not allowed to break a law just because they are at work.

I am not saying we don’t need good solid security policies as I strongly believe that policies are absolutely necessary and required as a way to share with our community the behaviors expected of them in the protection of organizational data but these policies should:

  • Cover topics and areas that are “gray” and that without a policy would require people to guess at the right thing to do
  • Be written in such a manner that helps define what steps are necessary for our community members to show they are in  compliance and showing due diligence in meeting the intent of applicable laws
  • Be enforceable and worthy of being enforced

It is important for Business Community members to follow their common sense in fulfilling their every day duties and tasks, if they do so the courts have ruled that they are most likely not going to be held personally liable for security breaches or security issues that occur.  In the InfoSec field we call this safety net the principles of “due diligence” or being “prudent” both of which are just other ways of saying making reasonable and common sense decisions.   However, the courts have also ruled that failure to use common sense in the protection of data and the securing of an IT infrastructure is grounds for holding a person personally liable.

Companies are firing IT staff that have failed to use common sense decisions in the protection of data and securing the IT infrastructure they are responsible for.  This makes it critical that in areas where it is not clear what approach constitutes common sense we protect our Business Community members by having policies in place that provide Business Community members with clear and concise instructions on what actions and activities they should or should not be doing.  For example:  If State Law requires that we protect SSNs we do not need a policy that says we have to protect SSN, the law already says that, but we may need a policy that describes ways of protecting SSNs such as using disk or file encryption, using a different type of identifier, database encryption of the field which stores the SSN, not storing or using an SSN in places where it is really not necessary to do so, etcetera.

Said another way, we should write policies that help non-security Business Community members understand what the common sense ways of protecting and safeguarding  data look like.  That’s just good Common Sense.

© Kevin L. McLaughlin, probably cited re-use is acceptable